The Channel Diagnostic
Sample findings brief
This is the document a Channel Diagnostic ends with. Short, plain, and built to be acted on. It has the same four parts as every brief I write.
The company, as given
| Profile | Detail |
|---|---|
| Business | Manufacturer of plumbing and HVAC supplies, sold through distributors |
| Revenue | $68M a year through the distributor channel |
| Channel | 132 distributors, 5 regions, roughly 9,800 retail accounts |
| Data reviewed | 24 months of sales by distributor, 12 months of forecast history, one full year of incentive payouts |
| The owner's question | "Sales are flat and margin keeps slipping. I cannot tell which distributors are actually earning their keep." |
The scorecard
Six dimensions, scored 1 to 5 against the evidence in the data provided. A low score is not an insult. It is a pointer to where the money is.
| Dimension | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Distributor ROI | ●●●●●2 | Profit after incentives and freight is calculated for 31 of 132 distributors. The other 101 are ranked on shipments alone. |
| Forecast accuracy | ●●●●●2 | Monthly forecast error averaged 21% over the last year. Two regions land within 8%. Three miss by 25% or more, in both directions. |
| Incentive efficiency | ●●●●●1 | 78% of incentive spend went to the top 12 distributors. Payouts are calculated on shipments in. Sell-through is not part of the calculation. |
| Stock availability | ●●●●●2 | 11 of the 40 fastest-moving products stocked out at distributor level at least once a quarter. The same products carry excess stock two regions away. |
| Retailer participation | ●●●●●2 | 17% of active retailers earned any incentive last year. The rate has been flat for three years, so the program is a discount for a few, not a driver for the many. |
| Reporting and visibility | ●●●●●3 | Monthly sales reporting by distributor is consistent and on time. Margin, returns, and inventory sit in separate reports that nobody joins up. |
The brief, in four parts
1. What is visible
Shipments by distributor, monthly, for 24 months, and they are clean. The owner can see who buys, how much, and in which months. The top 12 distributors account for 54% of channel revenue, and the ranking has barely moved in two years.
2. What is missing
Profit per distributor for 101 of the 132. Sell-through at retail, which is collected by nobody. Inventory ageing at distributor level. Without those three, every channel decision is being made on the one number that flatters the channel most: shipments in.
3. Where spend and sales line up
They mostly do not. Incentive money follows shipments, so it concentrates on the largest distributors whether or not their retailers sell the product through. An estimated $610K of last year's $1.9M incentive spend went to distributors whose sell-through fell year over year. The program is paying for loading, not for selling.
4. Three fixes, ranked
The three changes most likely to pay back first, in order. Each one names what I found, what it costs, and the fix.
Fix 1 · Pays back first
Pay for sell-through, not just sell-in
What I found: incentives are earned on shipments into the distributor, with no second condition. Distributors can earn in full while their retailers' sales fall.
What it costs: roughly $610K a year paid against declining sell-through, on the sample year's figures, plus the margin given up in the discount itself.
The fix: an incentive redesign with two triggers. A base earning on sell-in, and the larger share earned only when sell-through grows. Pilot it with 20 distributors for one quarter before rolling it out.
Fix 2
Put the forecast on a discipline
What I found: a 21% average forecast error, swinging both ways. The same error produces excess stock in two regions and stock-outs in three, on the same products, in the same months.
What it costs: an estimated $340K a year in carrying cost on the excess, before counting the sales lost on the 11 fast movers that keep running out.
The fix: forecast discipline. One monthly forecast per distributor for the top products, the error published next to it every month, and a short review that asks only one question: why did we miss?
Fix 3
Measure every distributor on profit, then act on the tail
What I found: 101 distributors have never had a profit figure attached to them. On the sample data, the bottom 40 by shipments contribute about 2% of gross margin while taking roughly 18% of field support time.
What it costs: field time and support cost spent where the return is thinnest, while the distributors in the middle, the ones with room to grow, get what is left.
The fix: a distributor ROI view for all 132: revenue, incentive cost, freight, returns, and support time in one place. Segment the channel into grow, fix, and exit conversations, in that order. Fix before exit, always.
The first 90 days
| When | What changes | What the owner should see |
|---|---|---|
| Days 1 to 30 | Build the distributor profit view for all 132. Start publishing forecast error monthly, by distributor. | The first honest ranking of the channel: who earns, who costs, who is unknown. |
| Days 31 to 60 | Pilot the two-trigger incentive with 20 distributors. Set availability targets for the 11 problem products. | Participation and sell-through moving in the pilot group, and stock-outs starting to fall. |
| Days 61 to 90 | Decide the rollout on pilot evidence. Open the first fix conversations with the tail, using their own numbers. | A forecast error trend pointing down, and a channel conversation based on profit, not volume. |
You can act on the brief without me
That is deliberate. A real brief is yours to use with your own team. If you would rather have help with the fixes, that is a second conversation, and it starts only if the findings earn it.
A live diagnostic needs three things you already have: sales by distributor, your forecast history, and what you paid out in incentives. A spreadsheet export is enough, and I sign a confidentiality agreement before I see any of it.